Exciting, right? But also, let’s be real—a little nerve-wracking.
This is where underwriting comes in.
It’s not just crunching numbers or running credit scores; it’s the art and science of deciding who’s a good bet and who’s a risky leap. Done well, underwriting can mean the difference between a profitable portfolio and sleepless nights wondering if you’re going to get that money back.
The good news? You don’t need a crystal ball to be a great underwriter. You just need the right tools, a solid process, and a keen eye for the red (and green!) flags. In this guide, we’ll break down MCA underwriting from the ground up—no jargon, no fluff.
No matter if you’re just getting started or looking to sharpen your skills, you’ll walk away knowing exactly how to size up deals, spot hidden risks, and master the art of saying “yes” (or “no”) with confidence.
So grab your coffee and let’s dive in—we’ll start with the fundamentals.
What is MCA underwriting, exactly?
Alright, let’s break it down. merchant cash advance underwriting is basically the process of figuring out if a business is a good candidate for a merchant cash advance.
It’s like being a detective, accountant, and business coach all rolled into one. Your job is to dig into the numbers, evaluate the risks, and decide if it’s a win-win: the merchant gets the funding they need, and you (or your company) get a reasonable shot at getting paid back—plus that sweet return.
Unlike traditional loans, MCAs aren’t based on assets or credit scores alone. You’re advancing cash today, and the merchant pays it back each and every day (just like it says in the agreement—until it’s fully paid off, so track your syndication tight). That means you’re not just looking at their past; you’re betting on their future.
Exciting? Definitely. Risky? Oh, you bet.
So, what does the underwriting process actually involve? In practical terms, it’s about answering some key questions:
- Can this business handle the repayment? You’re looking at their cash flow, revenue trends, and expenses to make sure they can pay you back without tanking their business.
- Are they consistent? Seasonal dips? Spiky revenue? It’s all about figuring out if their income can support steady repayments, even during the slow months.
- Are there red flags? Maybe they’ve bounced checks, defaulted on other advances, or have a long list of unhappy creditors. Not necessarily a deal-breaker, but definitely something to dig into.
At its core, merchant cash advance underwriting isn’t about saying “yes” to everyone—it’s about saying “yes” to the right ones. The goal is to minimize risk while still giving businesses the cash they need to thrive.
It’s a balancing act, but once you get the hang of it, it’s super rewarding. You’re not just crunching numbers; you’re helping businesses grow and succeed.
And hey, that’s a pretty great feeling.
Now that we know what MCA underwriting is, let’s peek behind the curtain—what does an MCA underwriter actually do all day? Spoiler: it’s more than just crunching numbers.
What does an MCA underwriter actually do?
So, what’s an MCA underwriter’s day really like? Is it all spreadsheets, MCA reports and dashboards, and stress? Well, kind of—but there’s more to it than that.
Your job is to figure out if a deal makes sense, keep the risk manageable, and ensure both your company and the merchant walk away happy.
Here’s the rundown of what you actually do:
1. Dive into the numbers (like a detective with a calculator)
First stop? The merchant’s bank statements.
This is where you piece together the puzzle of their business. You’re looking at deposits, withdrawals, and overall cash flow.
Do they have steady revenue? Are they overdrafting like crazy? Do their expenses make sense?
It’s all about spotting patterns that tell you whether this business can handle the repayment plan.
2. Assess risk (a.k.a., don’t let the red flags fool you)
Every business comes with risks, but some are bigger than others. As an underwriter, you’re on the lookout for things like:
- Bounced checks: A big warning sign that cash flow might be tight.
- Inconsistent deposits: If their revenue is all over the place, it might be tough for them to handle regular repayments.
- Multiple MCA advances: Stacking advances can spell trouble—you don’t want to be the last one at the repayment buffet.
Your job is to separate the “manageable” risks from the “run for the hills” risks.
3. Analyze their story (numbers only tell half the tale)
Yes, data is important, but context is king.
Maybe a merchant had a rough month because of a one-off event—like a broken oven at their restaurant or a slow holiday season. You need to weigh the human side of the story, too.
Great underwriters know when to dig deeper and when to trust their gut.
4. Crunch the offer (and make sure it works for everyone)
Once you’ve assessed the risks, it’s time to structure the deal.
How much can you advance? What’s a reasonable repayment rate?
You’re creating an offer that helps the merchant without setting them up for failure. It’s like building a bridge—you want it sturdy enough to carry both of you across safely.
Meet your MCA underwriting wingman
Tired of juggling deals and drowning in data? OrgMeter’s got your back—it’s the CRM built to keep your MCA game sharp and streamlined.
5. Say yes, no, or maybe (and back it up)
At the end of the day, your job is to make the call. Approve the deal, deny it, or ask for more info.
But here’s the catch: your decision needs to make sense. No matter if you’re explaining it to the sales team, the merchant, or your boss—you need to back it up with solid reasoning.
6. Keep learning (the MCA world is always changing)
Every deal teaches you something new. A good underwriter keeps sharpening their skills, learning about industries, trends, software that can support the business, and the sneaky tricks some merchants might try to pull.
It’s a dynamic role, and the best underwriters embrace that.
Okay, we’ve got the job description down, but how does the whole process actually play out? Let’s break it down step by step.
How does the MCA underwriting process work?
Alright, so now that we’ve covered what merchant cash advance underwriting is and what underwriters actually do, let’s zoom in on the how. What’s the step-by-step process to go from a merchant application to a final thumbs up (or down)?
Think of it like making a great cup of coffee: there’s a method to the madness, and every step matters. Here’s your merchant cash advance underwriting guidelines:
Step 1: The application hits your desk
The underwriting process starts when a merchant submits their application. You’ll typically get:
- Basic business details (name, industry, time in business, etc.)
- Recent bank statements (usually 3-6 months’ worth)
- Credit scores (not as critical as with traditional lending but still useful)
Pro tip: The quality of the application can tell you a lot about the merchant. If it’s a mess, that might be a red flag for how they run their business.
Step 2: Scrub the bank statements
This is where the magic happens. You’re looking for:
- Revenue trends: Are deposits steady or all over the place?
- Daily balances: Do they keep enough in the account to cover operating costs (and your repayment)?
- Bounced checks/NSFs: Too many of these are a big red flag.
Your goal is to get a clear picture of the business’s cash flow. Can they handle repayment without straining their operations? If yes, move on (pro tip: automate your commission tracking—it’ll save you weeks of time!). If no, pause and dig deeper.
Step 3: Risk assessment (a.k.a. playing CSI: MCA)
Once you’ve looked at the numbers, it’s time to assess the risks. Here’s where you ask the tough questions:
- Are they stacking other MCAs?
- Do they have existing liens or debts?
- Is their industry high-risk (think nightclubs or seasonal businesses)?
At this stage, you’re building a profile: is this merchant likely to succeed and repay, or is there too much uncertainty?
Step 4: Context is king
Numbers are only part of the story. Now, you consider the context:
- Seasonality: Maybe a dip in revenue makes sense if they’re a ski rental shop in July.
- One-time hits: Did they have a major expense (like equipment repair) that threw off their numbers?
- Growth potential: Is this advance going to help them grow (new equipment, inventory, etc.)?
Good underwriting isn’t just black and white—it’s understanding the shades of gray.
Step 5: Structure the deal
If everything checks out, it’s time to structure the advance. This means deciding:
- The advance amount: What can you comfortably offer?
- The repayment percentage: A rate that works for both you and the merchant.
- The term: How long will they take to pay it back?
The key is balance. You want the merchant to succeed while protecting your portfolio.
Step 6: Final approval and offer
Now comes the moment of truth. If the deal looks solid, you send it up the chain (or approve it yourself, depending on your setup). The merchant gets the offer, and if they accept—bam! Funding time.
If not, you may adjust or walk away.
Step 7: Monitor and learn
The process doesn’t end after funding. Keep an eye on repayment trends and look for patterns.
Every deal you fund (or don’t) adds to your expertise, so take notes, learn, and refine your process.
The CRM your MCA deals deserve
Don’t let disorganization kill your deals. OrgMeter keeps your underwriting process smooth, smart, and always on point.
The MCA underwriting process is like a well-oiled machine: every step has its purpose. And while it may seem daunting at first, once you’ve run through it a few times, it becomes second nature.
Plus, when you see a merchant thrive because of a deal you approved, it’s all worth it.
Alright, we’ve got the process roadmap—but what are these underwriters really hunting for in all those applications? Let’s dig into the key factors.
What factors are underwriters looking for?
Alright, let’s get to the nitty-gritty: what exactly are underwriters looking at when they evaluate an MCA application? Think of it as piecing together a puzzle.
Each factor gives you a clue about whether this merchant is a solid bet—or a risky gamble. Here’s what’s under the microscope:
1. Revenue consistency (the big one)
Underwriters love steady, predictable revenue. Why? Because MCAs are repaid as a percentage on a daily basis.
If deposits are bouncing around like a ping-pong ball, it’s harder to gauge whether they can handle regular repayments.
What you’re looking for:
- Regular deposits (daily, weekly, monthly—whatever fits their business).
- A healthy monthly total.
- No massive gaps in revenue without a good reason (like a seasonal slowdown).
Red flag: Wild swings in revenue or long dry spells with no deposits.
2. Daily ending balances (cash cushion)
Think of the daily balance as a business’s financial breathing room. It’s the leftover cash after expenses, and it tells you how much wiggle room they have.
What you’re looking for:
- Consistently positive daily balances.
- Enough cash to cover operating costs AND MCA repayments (Just a pro tip: think about automating payment collections—it’ll save you a ton of hassle!).
Red flag: Frequent overdrafts or balances hovering near zero.
3. NSFs and bounced checks (ouch!)
These are the bank account’s way of screaming, “We’re struggling!” While a few non-sufficient funds incidents might be manageable, a pattern of them is a big deal.
What you’re looking for:
- Minimal NSFs in the past 3-6 months.
- A clear explanation if NSFs show up (e.g., one-time mistake or timing issue).
Red flag: Repeated NSFs with no explanation.
4. Existing debt (are they stacking?)
Underwriters hate debt stacking (taking multiple MCAs at once) because it spreads repayment obligations too thin.
Your job is to figure out how deep in the debt pool this merchant already is.
What you’re looking for:
- Existing MCA repayments.
- Other business loans or liens.
Red flag: Multiple active MCAs or excessive debt compared to revenue.
5. Industry type (risky business?)
Some industries are riskier than others. A local diner with loyal customers? Pretty stable. A nightclub that relies on weekend crowds? Riskier.
What you’re looking for:
- Industries with steady demand (restaurants, retail, services).
- A clear plan for riskier industries (like seasonal or niche businesses).
Red flag: High-risk industries without mitigating factors (e.g., nightlife, adult entertainment, gambling).
6. Time in business (New vs. Established)
How long a merchant has been in business matters. Established businesses with a track record are usually safer bets than startups still finding their footing.
What you’re looking for:
- 6+ months of business operation (the longer, the better).
- A proven track record of consistent revenue.
Red flag: A brand-new business with no history.
7. Purpose of the advance (what’s the plan?)
Why does the merchant need the funds? A clear, sensible reason (e.g., buying inventory, expanding operations) is a good sign.
Vague or questionable answers? Not so much.
What you’re looking for:
- A specific, business-focused use for the funds.
- Evidence that the advance will help generate more revenue.
Red flag: No clear plan or using the advance to cover other debt.
8. Credit scores (not a dealbreaker, but still helpful)
In the MCA world, credit scores aren’t as critical as they are in traditional lending, but they still provide valuable context.
What you’re looking for:
- Decent personal and/or business credit (shows financial responsibility).
- A history of paying obligations on time.
Red flag: Extremely low credit scores without other compensating factors.
9. Seasonality (does it make sense?)
Some businesses naturally ebb and flow with the seasons. A ski rental shop’s winter boom and summer bust isn’t a dealbreaker—if you understand the rhythm.
What you’re looking for:
- A logical revenue pattern for their industry.
- Evidence they’ve navigated slow seasons before.
Red flag: No clear plan for managing revenue dips.
At the end of the day, underwriters are looking for one big thing: confidence. Can this merchant repay the advance without putting their business at risk? By digging into these factors, you’re building a complete picture that helps you answer that question.
And remember, it’s not just about saying “yes” or “no”—it’s about finding a deal structure that works for everyone. When you get it right, everybody wins!
Now that we know what underwriters look for, let’s talk about paper grades—a fancy term that packs a serious punch when it comes to deals.
What are MCA paper grades (and why do they matter)?
Let’s talk about MCA paper grades—the behind-the-scenes lingo that makes underwriters sound super fancy.
But don’t worry, it’s not rocket science.
Paper grades are simply a way to categorize deals based on their risk level. They help you decide how much to advance, what terms to offer, and how nervous you should be about getting paid back.
Think of paper grades as the report card for a deal. Here’s the breakdown:
“A” paper (the honor roll)
These are your chef’s kiss deals.
The merchant has strong, consistent revenue, no NSF issues, and a solid daily balance. They’ve been in business for a while, their industry is stable, and they’ve got minimal debt. In other words, they’re the golden child of MCA deals.
Why it matters: With “A” paper, you can confidently offer a larger advance, longer terms, and more favorable repayment rates. It’s low risk and likely smooth sailing.
“B” paper (solid but not perfect)
These merchants are good but not flawless. Maybe they have a few NSFs or a slightly lower daily balance.
Their revenue might fluctuate a bit, but overall, they’re dependable.
Why it matters: “B” paper is still a solid bet, but you might tighten the terms a bit—offer a slightly smaller advance or a shorter repayment period to manage the risk.
“C” paper (the wild cards)
This is where things get dicey. Merchants in this category have notable red flags: inconsistent revenue, a history of NSFs, stacking other MCAs, or operating in a high-risk industry.
They’re not hopeless, but they’re a gamble.
Why it matters: With “C” paper, you’re taking on more risk. To offset that, you’ll likely offer a smaller advance, shorter terms, and higher repayment percentages. Proceed with caution—and only if the numbers still make sense.
Organizing MCA paper grades has never been easier. With OrgMeter, every deal is a no-brainer. Ready to ace the underwriting game?
“D” or “F” paper (the hard pass)
These are the deals you just walk away from.
The merchant’s bank account is a mess, their revenue is unpredictable, and their debt levels are through the roof. There’s no reasonable path to repayment without seriously hurting their business—or your portfolio.
Why it matters: Knowing when to say no is just as important as knowing when to say yes. A bad deal can drain your resources and lead to headaches down the line.
Why do paper grades matter and how to grade an MCA paper? Because paper grades help you:
- Set expectations: You know what kind of risk you’re taking and can structure the deal accordingly.
- Protect your portfolio: By categorizing deals, you avoid overexposing yourself to high-risk merchants.
- Stay consistent: Grading creates a standard process, so you’re not making decisions on a whim.
To assign a grade, you evaluate factors like:
- Monthly revenue (how much and how consistent it is).
- NSF activity (frequent or rare?).
- Daily balances (do they keep a healthy cushion?).
- Time in business (established or new kid on the block?).
- Industry risk level (stable or unpredictable?).
- Existing debt load (manageable or drowning?).
The more boxes they check in the “low risk” column, the better their grade.
Easy, right?
At the end of the day, paper grades are a tool to make your underwriting smarter and more predictable. They give you a quick snapshot of a deal’s risk level so you can make better decisions—and keep your portfolio thriving. Because let’s face it, nobody wants to fund an F-paper deal.
Grades in hand, it’s time to gear up! Here’s a killer tool—OrgMeter—to help you master MCA underwriting like a pro.
Your MCA underwriting toolkit → OrgMeter
Underwriting can feel like herding cats, but OrgMeter, your perfect merchant cash advance underwriting software, turns chaos into clarity. It’s the ultimate platform to streamline your workflow, cut down on manual tasks, and make smarter decisions—fast.
Here’s what makes it a literal lifesaver for MCA businesses:
- Automated statement analysis: No more number-crunching; get instant insights.
- Efficient underwriting: Handle more deals with less hassle.
- Centralized partner access: Everyone stays on the same page—no email ping-pong.
- In-depth reporting: Spot trends, minimize risks, and make data-backed calls.
- Syndication tracking: Easily manage and optimize funding partnerships.
- API integrations: Connect your tools for seamless workflows.
With $7.5B funded and 2M+ submissions processed, OrgMeter is trusted by MCA pros who mean business. Ready to simplify underwriting and boost your bottom line? This is your toolkit, and it’s time to give OrgMeter a try!